ISAuditPrep

Exam technique

Think like an IS auditor: answering BEST, FIRST and MOST questions

· 6 min read

Many CISA® candidates know the material and still lose points on questions where every option sounds sensible. The exam rewards a specific way of thinking: that of an independent IS auditor who focuses on risk and evidence. Once you adopt that mindset, many "two good answers" questions become much easier.

Read the keyword first

Look for the word in capitals: BEST, FIRST, MOST, GREATEST, PRIMARY, LEAST. It tells you what kind of answer is wanted.

  • FIRST asks about order. The right answer is often a step that must come before the others, such as understanding the business, assessing risk or gathering evidence.
  • BEST asks you to compare. Several options may be valid controls; pick the one that addresses the root cause or covers the risk most completely.
  • GREATEST or MOST significant risk asks for the impact on the organisation, not the most technical issue.

Five habits of the auditor mindset

1. The auditor reviews and reports; management fixes

An IS auditor stays independent. Options in which the auditor implements a control, changes a configuration or approves a system are usually wrong. The auditor identifies the issue, assesses it and reports it, and management decides on and carries out the fix.

2. Risk comes before controls

You can only judge whether a control is adequate once you know the risk it should address. When asked what to do first in an audit, look for options about understanding the business process and assessing risk.

3. Evidence before conclusions

If something looks wrong, the next step is usually to gather or verify evidence, not to report a finding straight away. Evidence obtained directly by the auditor is more reliable than statements from the people being audited.

4. Preventive beats detective, detective beats corrective

When comparing controls, a control that stops a problem from happening is generally stronger than one that notices it afterwards. Automated controls are usually more reliable than manual ones.

5. Think business impact

The greatest risk is the one that most affects the organisation's objectives, data or customers. A missing patch on a test server matters less than unrestricted access to production payment data.

A worked example

During an audit, an IS auditor finds that several developers have write access to the production environment. What should the auditor do FIRST?

  1. Remove the developers' access.
  2. Report the finding to the audit committee.
  3. Determine whether compensating controls exist and whether changes were made without authorisation.
  4. Recommend a segregation-of-duties policy.

Option 1 breaks independence: the auditor doesn't change access. Options 2 and 4 come later. The best first step is 3: understand the actual risk and gather evidence before concluding. That pattern (assess, verify, then report) returns in many questions.

Practise the reasoning, not just the facts

When you review practice questions, ask for each wrong option why an auditor would not choose it. After a few hundred questions, you will start to recognise the patterns. Every ISAuditPrep question comes with an explanation written to show this reasoning.